Steakhouses in Indianapolis

At Del Frisco's Double Eagle Steakhouse in Indianapolis, Indiana, you'll step into a world where elegance meets comfort. The ambiance is a perfect blend of upscale, chic, and romantic vibes, making it an ideal spot for a special date night. The atmosphere is lively yet sophisticated, often enhanced by the delightful tunes of live music, including piano and singing, which really adds to the experience. The restaurant prides itself on being a fine-dining establishment, and it shows in the high-quality service and ingredients. You'll be greeted by a sommelier ready to guide you through their wine selection, and if you're driving, valet service makes your arrival and departure smooth and hassle-free. When it comes to the steaks, they're the star of the show here. The filet mignon is often cooked to perfection, melting in your mouth with its tenderness. The ribeye is another favorite, praised for its rich flavor, though occasionally it might be overcooked. If you're in the mood for something different, try the Wagyu meatballs, which have received positive feedback. For seafood lovers, the lobster mac and cheese and surf and turf options are a must-try, and the crab cakes are another delicious choice. On the side, the creamed spinach is a rich and creamy delight that complements any main dish. Don't skip dessert; the butter cake is a crowd-pleaser and highly recommended. And if you're looking to enjoy a drink, the cocktail menu, especially the martini variations, is top-notch and well worth exploring. Overall, Del Frisco's Double Eagle Steakhouse offers a memorable dining experience with its exceptional ambiance, quality steaks, and thoughtful touches that make every visit special.

At Terra Gaucha Brazilian Steakhouse in Indianapolis, Indiana, the ambiance is a mix of lively, upscale, and sophisticated vibes, though some find it a bit too crowded and loud. It's definitely a fine-dining spot with high-quality ingredients and top-notch service, perfect for special occasions. However, the lighting can be a bit too bright for some, reminiscent of a fast-food joint. The steaks here are a hit or miss; many rave about the tender, juicy filet mignon and ribeye, but there have been complaints about inconsistent cooking, with some steaks coming out overcooked or undercooked. If you're into cocktails, you're in luck - the Key Lime Martini and Caipirinha are favorites among patrons. For dessert, the chocolate mousse is a solid choice that's been well-received. The picanha is another highlight, often praised for its quality and preparation. As for seafood, it's a bit of a mixed bag, so you might want to stick to the steaks and cocktails for a safer bet.

At Steak Shrimp in Indianapolis, Indiana, the atmosphere is clean and wonderful, perfect for a casual, family-friendly dining experience. The focus here is clearly on the food and service, with no frills or fancy distractions. While one review did mention a dry chicken dish, the steak offerings, like steak nachos and Philly steak, receive positive feedback. Additionally, they offer a unique surf and turf option with lobster paired with steak. Overall, Steak Shrimp is a great spot for those looking for a straightforward, enjoyable meal in a welcoming environment.

At Geraldine's Supper Club & Lounge in Indianapolis, Indiana, you'll find a dining experience that's both intimate and inviting. The ambiance here is cozy and warm, perfect for a special evening out. The atmosphere is enhanced by live music, which adds a unique touch to your meal, whether you're looking for a romantic date night or a celebratory dinner. The steak selection at Geraldine's is a highlight, with options like filet mignon, ribeye, and the renowned Beef Wellington. Diners often rave about the quality and flavor of the steaks, which are cooked to perfection and served with generous portions. However, some have noted that the steaks can be hit or miss, with occasional issues regarding tenderness and cooking temperature. Seafood lovers will appreciate the variety of dishes available, including oysters and lobster, which are often described as fresh and well-prepared. The sides, such as crab cakes and mashed potatoes, are also popular and add to the overall dining experience. Desserts at Geraldine's are a sweet finish to your meal, with favorites like bread pudding and crème brûlée receiving high praise. The drink menu is equally impressive, featuring well-crafted cocktails that complement the meal nicely. While the service is generally friendly and attentive, there have been some reports of inconsistency, particularly on busy nights. The overall experience at Geraldine's is considered worth the price by many, though some feel the cost can be a bit steep for what they receive. In summary, Geraldine's Supper Club & Lounge offers a memorable dining experience with its inviting atmosphere, delicious steaks, and a variety of seafood and side dishes. It's a great choice for those looking to enjoy a special night out in Indianapolis.

Indy Steak & Lemonade in Indianapolis, Indiana, is a go-to spot for Philly steak lovers. The Philly steak sandwiches here are a hit, often praised for their quick preparation and delicious taste. Some folks mention that the sandwich can be a bit on the bread-heavy side, but overall, it's still enjoyed by many. The steak itself is a standout, with several customers calling it the best around. If you're in the mood for something fresh and yummy, their fries are a popular choice too. While the food gets a lot of love, there was an instance where the staff's strict adherence to rules during the COVID season left a customer feeling a bit let down. Despite this, the place has become a favorite for some locals, especially those on the west side. If you're looking for a satisfying Philly steak experience, Indy Steak & Lemonade might just be your spot.

Murphy's Steakhouse in Indianapolis, Indiana, offers a unique dining experience that blends the ambiance of a sports bar with the elegance of a steakhouse. The atmosphere is lively, often featuring live music that can make conversation a bit challenging but adds to the fun vibe. The place has a nostalgic feel with leather booths and cozy lighting, appealing to an older crowd but welcoming to all. The standout feature of Murphy's is its mushroom medley appetizer, which has received high praise for its perfectly seasoned breading and delicious taste. The menu is affordable, with a variety of options that cater to different tastes, though the steak quality can be hit or miss. Some diners have enjoyed tender and flavorful steaks, while others have found them tough and overcooked. Service at Murphy's is generally friendly and attentive, though there have been instances of slow service and issues with drink refills. The food comes out quickly, which is a plus for those looking for a speedy meal. Overall, Murphy's Steakhouse is a local gem that offers a casual yet enjoyable dining experience, perfect for those looking to enjoy a meal with friends or family in a relaxed setting.

At Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse in Indianapolis, Indiana, you'll find a dining experience that's hard to beat. The ambiance here is top-notch, with a welcoming vibe that makes you feel like a VIP from the moment you walk in. The place has a cool, upscale feel with live music that adds to the relaxed yet elegant atmosphere. It's the kind of spot where you can enjoy a special occasion or just a nice night out. The standout feature of Hyde Park is definitely the service. The staff goes above and beyond to make sure you're taken care of, often remembering personal details and making you feel right at home. They're knowledgeable about the menu and always ready to help you choose the perfect dish. When it comes to steaks, Hyde Park doesn't disappoint. Whether you're in the mood for a classic ribeye or something more unique like the Australian Wagyu, the steaks are cooked to perfection and packed with flavor. They're tender, juicy, and everything you'd want from a high-end steakhouse. Desserts here are a treat, with options like a flaming banana butter cake that's as delicious as it is entertaining. The drinks menu is impressive too, with well-crafted cocktails and a selection of wines that pair beautifully with your meal. Overall, Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse offers a memorable dining experience that combines great food, excellent service, and a fantastic atmosphere. It's a must-visit if you're in Indianapolis looking for a special night out.

At Tony's of Indianapolis in Indianapolis, Indiana, you'll step into an ambiance that's all about upscale elegance with a cozy, intimate vibe. The place is perfect for a romantic evening or a special date night, with live jazz or smooth music adding to the classy atmosphere. The service is top-notch, with servers who double as sommeliers, guiding you through an impressive wine selection. When it comes to the food, the steaks are the stars of the show. The filet mignon, ribeye, and porterhouse are all highly praised for their tenderness and flavor, often described as melt-in-your-mouth delicious. If you're in the mood for something different, the prime rib sliders are a tasty choice. For dessert, don't miss out on the chocolate mousse or the chocolate dessert cup, both of which are highlights on the menu. And if you're looking to enjoy a drink, the cocktails, especially the martinis like the chocolate martini, are well-made and strong. On the seafood front, the crab cakes are a must-try, considered a signature dish, and the oysters are a great way to start your meal. Valet parking makes your visit even more convenient, ensuring a smooth and enjoyable dining experience at Tony's.

At Prime 47 in Indianapolis, Indiana, you can expect a mixed dining experience. The ambiance varies from quiet and conducive to conversation to sometimes noisy, depending on the crowd. The service can be hit or miss; while some visits are marked by attentive and friendly staff, others have reported slow service and a lack of attention to detail. The steak selection is extensive, featuring popular cuts like filet mignon, ribeye, and wagyu. However, the quality and cooking of the steaks can be inconsistent, with some diners raving about their perfectly cooked and flavorful meals, while others have been disappointed by overcooked or undercooked steaks. For seafood lovers, Prime 47 offers dishes like shrimp cocktail, lobster mac and cheese, and lobster bisque, which have received positive feedback for their quality and taste. The sides, such as creamed spinach and mushrooms, are also well-regarded, though some have found certain dishes lacking in flavor. Desserts at Prime 47 are a highlight for many, with offerings like bread pudding and chocolate chip cookies with ice cream being particularly praised. The drink menu is diverse, featuring well-crafted cocktails and a good selection of wines. Overall, Prime 47 offers a range of experiences, from exceptional to disappointing, so your visit might depend on luck and timing.