Steakhouses in Rochester

Delmonico's Italian Steakhouse in Rochester, New York, offers a dining experience that ranges from delightful to disappointing, depending on the visit. The ambiance is generally praised for being inviting and striking a nice balance between upscale and relaxed, perfect for special occasions like birthdays or anniversaries. However, some diners have noted issues with the atmosphere, such as loud music or an uncomfortable seating arrangement. The steakhouse features a variety of unique elements, including live music and themed decor, which contribute to a fun and engaging dining experience. Happy hour is a highlight for many, with a great selection of food and drinks at a good value. Steaks at Delmonico's are a mixed bag. The Delmonico steak is often mentioned as a favorite, praised for its tenderness and flavor. However, there have been complaints about the quality and consistency of other cuts, with some steaks arriving overcooked or lacking in seasoning. The filet mignon has received both praise and criticism, with some diners appreciating its tenderness while others found it lacking a proper crust. Seafood offerings, like the lobster tail and shrimp cocktail, are generally well-received, though there have been instances of undercooked or dry dishes. The crab cakes are a standout side dish, frequently described as the best some diners have ever had. Desserts, such as tiramisu and cannoli, are a highlight for many, often described as delicious and memorable. The drink menu, featuring martinis and cocktails, is also a strong point, with many patrons enjoying the variety and quality of the offerings. Overall, Delmonico's Italian Steakhouse in Rochester, New York, can offer a fantastic dining experience with its inviting ambiance, unique features, and standout dishes, but it's important to be aware of the potential for inconsistency in food quality and service.